When choosing between the SafePal X1 and SafePal S1, it’s easy to become indecisive. Yes, both wallets offer top-tier security and reliability, but how do you decide? With the X1’s Bluetooth and larger screen versus the S1’s offline-only setup, the decision comes down to your needs.
In this comparison of SafePal X1 vs SafePal S1, we’ll examine the strengths and weaknesses of each to help you find which model best fits your security and usability preferences.
What is SafePal X1?
The SafePal X1, introduced in 2021 by SafePal, is a hardware wallet designed to provide top-tier security and usability for cryptocurrency management. Manufactured by SafePal, a company based in Singapore and backed by Binance Labs, the X1 brings a modern twist with Bluetooth 5.0 connectivity, allowing for faster and more convenient transaction signing. It features a 1.8-inch display and is equipped with multiple layers of security, including an EAL 5+ secure element. It joins SafePal’s lineup, which includes the more affordable S1 and the advanced S1 Pro model.
What is SafePal S1?
Launched in 2018, the SafePal S1 is a secure, air-gapped hardware wallet created by SafePal, a Singaporean company supported by Binance Labs. The S1 offers strong offline security by using a fully air-gapped design, with no Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, or USB connections. It features a 1.3-inch color screen, a robust EAL 5+ secure element, and a long battery life. It’s an affordable choice for those looking for high security without the need for additional features, with the SafePal S1 Pro offering a more advanced version.
SafePal X1 vs SafePal S1: Design and Build
When I first held the SafePal X1, the 1.8-inch monochrome screen immediately stood out. It’s crisp, larger than the S1’s 1.3-inch display, and offers more space to view transaction details—something I appreciate when managing multiple wallets. The 12-button layout on the X1 makes navigation smoother and faster compared to the S1’s simpler D-pad. Despite the added buttons, the X1 feels lightweight and durable with its ABS+PVC body, though it doesn’t have the ultra-portable, credit-card-like form factor of the S1.
The SafePal S1, on the other hand, has a compact design that easily slips into your pocket, perfect for users who value portability. Its colorful 320×320 resolution screen is visually appealing, even though it’s smaller. The D-pad navigation feels intuitive for basic usage, but it’s not as efficient for more complex tasks. Both wallets have solid builds, but the X1’s larger size and more comprehensive buttons make it better suited for advanced users, while the S1 excels in simplicity and portability.
Security Features
Both wallets prioritize security, but they approach it differently. The SafePal X1 features an EAL5+ secure chip, multiple anti-tampering protections, and a Bluetooth 5.0 connection that’s designed to be highly secure for fast transactions. Even with Bluetooth, the X1 maintains an air-gapped mechanism, ensuring it’s still offline during crucial steps like private key management.
The SafePal S1, however, takes a no-compromise approach to offline security. With no Bluetooth, WiFi, NFC, or USB connectivity, it relies solely on QR code scanning for transaction signing. This eliminates any risk of remote hacking entirely. For anyone prioritizing maximum isolation from online threats, the S1 is the clear choice. That said, the X1 balances convenience with security, making it a better fit for users who want a modern, efficient signing experience without compromising on safety.
Connectivity and User Experience
The SafePal X1’s standout feature is its Bluetooth 5.0 connectivity, which allows me to sign transactions faster and more efficiently. Pairing it with my smartphone is seamless, and it integrates well with the SafePal app. This level of flexibility is a big upgrade compared to the S1, which lacks Bluetooth or any wireless connectivity. However, the S1’s QR-code-based system ensures that every action remains 100% offline approach, which is ideal for users who prioritize an ultra-secure environment.
While the X1 is designed for speed and modern convenience, the S1 keeps things simple and reliable. Scanning QR codes on the S1 is straightforward, though slower than Bluetooth. If you’re someone who frequently trades or moves assets, the X1’s speed makes a noticeable difference. On the other hand, the S1’s completely offline nature gives you peace of mind, knowing your device is isolated from online threats.
Battery Life and Performance
Battery performance is another area where the two wallets differ. The SafePal X1 comes with a 200mAh battery, which supports up to two hours of continuous use per charge. For me, this is more than sufficient for daily crypto management. Charging is quick via USB-C, which is a nice modern touch.
In contrast, the S1 features a 400mAh battery, offering up to 20 days of standby time with moderate daily use. It’s ideal for users who don’t want to worry about frequent recharging. However, the trade-off is the older USB charging method, which isn’t as fast or convenient as USB-C.
So if extended battery life is more important for you, then the S1 wins. However, for everyday users who value modern charging and quick use, the X1 holds its ground.
Display and Interface
One of the standout features of the SafePal X1 is its 1.8-inch monochrome screen with a 128×64 resolution. The larger display makes it easier to view transaction details clearly, which is especially helpful when managing long wallet addresses. I also appreciate the X1’s three-level backlight adjustment, which allows me to optimize screen brightness depending on the lighting—whether I’m indoors or outside. The multi-button keyboard adds to the usability, providing precise control and smooth navigation.
In contrast, the SafePal S1 comes with a 1.3-inch full-color screen with a higher 320×320 resolution. While smaller, the vibrant color display makes QR code scanning feel seamless and visually appealing. However, navigating with the S1’s D-pad can sometimes feel slower compared to the X1’s dedicated keyboard. If you value a larger display and customizable brightness, the X1 is more practical, but the S1’s sharp color screen offers a compact and stylish alternative. Would you like further refinements?
Portability and Durability
In terms of portability, both the X1 and S1 are lightweight and compact, but they cater to slightly different preferences. The S1 is about the size of a credit card, making it incredibly easy to slip into a wallet or pocket. Its sleek design and minimalistic build make it ideal for travel or on-the-go crypto management.
The X1, while still portable, feels slightly bulkier due to its larger screen and keyboard. Its ABS+PVC housing gives it a sturdy feel in hand, but it isn’t quite as discreet as the S1. Both devices are durable and built to last, but if you prioritize portability above all else, the S1 edges ahead, while the X1 balances portability with enhanced usability.
Languages and Compatibility
The SafePal X1 supports 10 languages, including English, Spanish, and Japanese, and promises future firmware updates for additional languages. This makes it flexible for international users.
On the other hand, the SafePal S1 supports an impressive 15 languages out of the box, offering broader global accessibility. Both wallets are compatible with iOS, Android, Windows, and MacOS, so you can seamlessly integrate them into your preferred ecosystem.
What’s in the Box?
The SafePal X1 package includes the hardware wallet, a USB-C cable for charging, a cleaning cloth, stickers, three mnemonic phrase cards, a user manual, and an app download card. It’s a thoughtful bundle that equips you with everything to get started.
The SafePal S1 package is nearly identical, though it includes a USB cable for charging instead of USB-C. The X1’s updated accessories feel slightly more modern, but both provide the essentials for secure crypto management.
Price and Value
When it comes to pricing, the SafePal X1 is offered at $69.99, while the SafePal S1 is more affordable at $49.99. The X1’s slightly higher cost reflects its additional features like Bluetooth 5.0 connectivity and a larger display.
From my experience, the X1 offers better usability and convenience, especially for users who manage transactions frequently. However, the S1 remains a great value for those prioritizing an air-gapped, fully offline device at a lower price point.
Pros and Cons of Each Model
When comparing the SafePal X1 vs SafePal S1 hardware wallets, it’s essential to weigh their strengths and limitations. Both wallets excel in different areas, making them suitable for different types of users. Here’s a quick overview to help you choose the right one:
SafePal X1: Pros and Cons
Pros |
Cons |
|---|---|
Bluetooth 5.0 connectivity for faster transactions |
Higher price at $69.99 |
Larger 1.8-inch monochrome display |
Slightly lower battery capacity (200mAh) |
Three-level backlight adjustment for visibility |
|
Compact, modern design with multi-button keyboard |
|
12-button layout for smoother operation |
SafePal S1: Pros and Cons
Pros |
Cons |
|---|---|
Affordable price at $49.99 |
No Bluetooth connectivity |
Fully air-gapped and offline for added security |
Smaller 1.3-inch display with lower resolution |
Supports 15 languages |
No backlight adjustment for screen |
Lightweight, compact, and travel-friendly |
|
Long-lasting 400mAh battery |
Both wallets are secure and versatile, but the choice depends on whether you value connectivity and usability or prefer a fully offline, budget-friendly option.
SafePal X1 vs SafePal S1: Which Should You Buy?
Choosing between the SafePal X1 and SafePal S1 depends on your needs and priorities. If you’re someone who values ease of use, offline security, and portability without needing advanced features, the SafePal S1 is a solid option, priced at $49.99. It offers robust security features like its EAL5+ chip and air-gapped design, making it ideal for users who want a straightforward, secure device without the need for connectivity.
On the other hand, if you prefer more modern functionalities and can justify a slightly higher price, the SafePal X1 at $69.99 brings additional connectivity with Bluetooth 5.0, which allows for faster and more efficient transaction signing. This makes it better suited for users who want more flexibility in managing their assets without being tethered to a USB cable. The larger 1.8” screen, enhanced navigation with 12 buttons, and additional language support also make it a more future-proof choice.
So in a nutshell, if you prioritize offline security and budget, go for the SafePal S1. But if you need more convenience, speed, and connectivity, the SafePal X1 will likely be the better fit for your needs.
Final Verdict
Without a doubt, this SafePal X1 vs SafePal S1 comparison has shown that both are excellent hardware wallets, each catering to different needs. If you prefer modern features like Bluetooth connectivity and a larger display, the X1 is the better choice. However, if you prioritize offline security, simplicity, and a more budget-friendly price, the S1 is a fantastic option. Choose the one that best suits your preferences without going wrong.
Read also ↓
Frequently Asked Questions
- What’s the main difference between SafePal X1 and S1?
The primary difference is connectivity. The SafePal X1 offers Bluetooth 5.0 for easier and faster transaction signing, while the SafePal S1 is fully air-gapped and does not have Bluetooth, relying on QR code scanning for offline transactions.
- Are both wallets compatible with the same cryptocurrencies?
Yes, both the SafePal X1 and S1 are compatible with a wide range of cryptocurrencies, supporting Bitcoin, Ethereum, and many altcoins. Both integrate with the SafePal App for managing your assets.
- How secure is the self-destruct feature on the wallets?
Both wallets feature a self-destruct mechanism to protect your funds in case of tampering. If unauthorized access is detected, the device erases all private keys, ensuring your assets remain safe, but note that this feature is more relevant when physical damage is involved.
- Which wallet has better screen resolution and display?
The SafePal X1 has a larger 1.8” monochrome screen with a 128×64 resolution, offering better visibility for transaction details. In contrast, the SafePal S1 has a 1.3” full-color screen with a 320×320 resolution, making the S1 more vibrant but smaller in size.
- Can I use both wallets for the same operating systems?
Yes, both wallets are compatible with iOS, Android, Windows, and MacOS, ensuring that you can easily manage your crypto assets across different platforms without issues.