SafePal S1 vs. Ledger Nano X: Which One Should You Buy?

Deciding between the SafePal S1 vs Ledger Nano X means understanding how their unique features cater to your crypto management style. Both are secure and reliable, but they differ in features, usability, and price. In this guide, I’ll help you compare these differences to pick the wallet that best matches your needs.

SafePal S1 vs Ledger Nano X – Side-by-Side Comparison

SafePal S1 vs Ledger Nano X – Overview

What is SafePal S1?

The SafePal S1 is a top-tier cryptocurrency hardware wallet introduced in 2018 by SafePal, a blockchain security company founded in Singapore and backed by Binance Labs. Featuring robust security features like an EAL5+ certified secure element and 100% air-gapped offline transactions, the S1 has become a leading choice for securing digital assets.

SafePal has since expanded its lineup with the S1 Pro and the compact X1 models, cementing its reputation as a trusted provider of cutting-edge crypto storage solutions.

Read the full SafePal S1 Review

What is Ledger Nano X?

Introduced in 2019 by Ledger, a French company specializing in crypto security, the Ledger Nano X is a premium hardware wallet designed for on-the-go use. With Bluetooth connectivity and support for 5,500+ cryptocurrencies, it offers seamless usability alongside advanced security features like a CC EAL5+ secure chip.

Ledger also offers models like the Nano S Plus, the sleek Ledger Flex, and the innovative Ledger Stax, catering to different user needs. The Nano X combines robust security with user-friendly features, making it ideal for those seeking convenience alongside strong protection.

Read the full Ledger Nano X review

Design and Build Quality

The SafePal S1 is compact and lightweight, roughly the size of a credit card, with an ABS+PVC casing that feels durable enough for daily use. Its 1.3-inch color screen and D-pad controls are intuitive, though the plastic construction might not feel as premium. Personally, I found the S1 to be highly portable and practical for its intended purpose, even if it doesn’t scream luxury.

The Ledger Nano X stands out with its brushed stainless steel and plastic design, giving it a premium, polished look. Its build feels robust, and at 34g, it’s heavier than the S1 but still very portable. During use, the Nano X’s 1.09-inch OLED screen and two-button navigation system felt sleek but required some getting used to. Overall, it delivers a more high-end feel compared to the SafePal S1.

Features and Connectivity

The SafePal S1 thrives on simplicity and security, offering a 100% air-gapped system that eliminates any connection risks. It has no Bluetooth, WiFi, NFC, or USB data transmission, relying solely on QR codes for transaction signing.

This approach provides unparalleled offline protection, and I’ve found it to be incredibly reassuring for safeguarding assets. While it doesn’t support advanced connectivity features, it covers the essentials for crypto storage and transactions efficiently.

The Ledger Nano X, however, is designed with versatility in mind. Its Bluetooth connectivity enables seamless pairing with smartphones, making it perfect for on-the-go users. It also features USB-C connectivity for those who prefer a wired setup. During my use, the ability to manage multiple wallets and sync with Ledger Live felt incredibly convenient, especially for handling diverse crypto portfolios.

While its connectivity is impressive, the wireless feature might not appeal to those who prioritize complete offline security.

Buy SafePal S1 →

Display and Usability

The SafePal S1 offers a 1.3-inch full-color screen, which I found clear and vibrant for viewing wallet details and scanning QR codes. Navigation is straightforward, thanks to its D-pad controls, and its user interface is simple yet effective. While it may lack the finesse of a premium wallet like the Ledger Flex, its usability focuses on function over form, which aligns perfectly with its security-first ethos.

In contrast, the Ledger Nano X opts for a 1.09-inch monochrome OLED display, which, although smaller than the S1’s screen, serves its purpose well. The two-button navigation system requires some practice but feels intuitive once you get the hang of it.

Personally, I found the screen size to be a slight drawback when reviewing complex transaction details, but its integration with the Ledger Live app compensates for any usability limitations.

SafePal S1 vs Ledger Nano X – Security Features

When it comes to security, the SafePal S1 leaves no stone unturned. Its EAL 5+ secure element, multiple layers of security sensors, and a self-destruct mechanism make it one of the safest options for crypto storage. I felt confident knowing my private keys were completely offline, with no risk of wireless hacking. The QR-code-only transaction signing further strengthens its air-gapped architecture, offering peace of mind for security-conscious users.

The Ledger Nano X also boasts an EAL 5+ certified secure chip, alongside its proprietary BOLOS operating system. It has an edge with ANSSI CSPN certification, which adds another layer of trust. While the Nano X offers robust security measures, its Bluetooth connectivity can be a concern for those who prefer an entirely offline wallet.

In my opinion, Nano X security features are strong enough for everyday use, but users handling large sums might prefer the S1 for its stricter offline capabilities.

Battery Life and Portability

The SafePal S1 features a built-in 400mAh battery, lasting up to 20 days with light usage. In my experience, it holds up well for sporadic transactions, but frequent users might find themselves recharging more often. Its credit-card-sized design and lightweight build make it extremely portable, easily slipping into a pocket or small bag.

The Ledger Nano X, with its 100mAh battery, offers up to five hours of continuous use. While its battery life may seem shorter, I appreciated that it charges quickly via USB-C, making it convenient for regular use. Its compact size and brushed stainless steel finish feel premium and durable, though it’s slightly bulkier compared to the S1.

For me, the Nano X strikes a balance between portability and premium build quality, though the S1 feels more travel-friendly for minimalists.

Supported Digital Assets and Compatibility

When it comes to supported digital assets, the SafePal S1 impresses with its wide range of compatibility, supporting over 9,000 cryptocurrencies and tokens including Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Solana. It also integrates seamlessly with decentralized applications (dApps) through the SafePal app, making it ideal for users engaged in DeFi. It is also compatible with iOS, Android, Windows, and macOS, ensuring accessibility across platforms. However, its lack of support for third-party wallets might limit flexibility for advanced users.

The Ledger Nano X, on the other hand, supports 500+ native coins and over 5,000 assets through third-party wallets, including Ethereum and Polygon NFTs. The Ledger Live app provides a streamlined experience for managing assets, staking, and more. I enjoyed its broader compatibility with third-party wallets, which opens up possibilities for advanced features. However, the limited compatibility with older devices could be a minor hurdle for some users.

What’s in the Box?

When unboxing the SafePal S1, here’s what you’ll find:

1. the wallet itself,
2. a USB cable for charging,
3. three mnemonic phrase cards,
4. a cleaning cloth, stickers,
5. a user manual, and
6. a download app card.

The inclusion of multiple mnemonic cards is a thoughtful touch, emphasizing the importance of backing up private keys. The packaging is simple but sufficient for what you’re getting at its price point.

Ledger Nano X’s unboxing experience leans towards premium, reflecting its higher price tag. Inside the box, you’ll find the following:

1. the wallet,
2. a USB-C to USB-A cable,
3. a keychain strap,
4. a getting-started leaflet, and
5. three recovery sheets.

While both wallets come with everything needed to get started, the Nano X’s accessories and premium feel slightly edge out the S1 for me, though the S1 remains practical and functional.

SafePal S1 vs Ledger Nano X – Price and Value

When it comes to price, the SafePal S1 is the more affordable option, retailing at $49.99. Despite its budget-friendly price, it offers a robust set of features, making it an excellent value for those prioritizing affordability without sacrificing essential security. I found its comprehensive security features particularly impressive for this price range.

The Ledger Nano X, priced at $149, is more than double the cost of the S1. However, its additional features, such as Bluetooth connectivity, broader third-party wallet compatibility, and premium build quality, justify the price for those who need versatility and convenience.

Yes, both wallets deliver solid value in their respective niches, but if you ask me, the Nano X feels like a premium choice for those willing to invest in added convenience and compatibility.

Buy SafePal S1 →

Pros and Cons

Here’s a quick look at the strengths and drawbacks of both wallets to help you decide:

SafePal S1: Pros and Cons

Ledger Nano X: Pros and Cons

You have seen so far that both wallets have their standout qualities. But which is the best? How can you make the right choice?

SafePal S1 vs. Ledger Nano X: Which Should You Buy?

Deciding between the SafePal S1 and Ledger Nano X depends on what you value most in a hardware wallet. If security is your top priority, both wallets excel, but they take different approaches. The SafePal S1 is fully air-gapped, making it ideal for offline storage, while the Ledger Nano X combines robust security with Bluetooth for added convenience.

For unique features, the Nano X’s ability to connect via Bluetooth and support for 5,000+ cryptocurrencies and NFTs makes it stand out for advanced users managing diverse portfolios. On the other hand, the SafePal S1 offers excellent affordability without compromising security, making it a great option for those on a budget.

In terms of usability, I find the Ledger Nano X more practical for day-to-day crypto management due to its larger app support and compatibility with the Ledger Live app. However, the SafePal S1 is easier to set up and simpler for those who want a straightforward cold storage option.

If price is your deciding factor, the SafePal S1 is cheaper at $49.99, while the Nano X is more expensive at $149, due to its premium features and design. So, if this is your first time buying a hardware wallet, the SafePal S1 is a solid choice. For experienced users wanting a more versatile wallet, the Ledger Nano X is worth the investment.

I’d like to say again that both wallets provide strong security, so the best choice depends on your preferred balance of features, usability, and cost.

Where to Buy Each Model

For the SafePal S1, purchasing directly from the SafePal website is the safest option to avoid counterfeit devices. Buying two or more units qualifies you for free global shipping (excluding leather cases), and you’ll enjoy benefits like a one-year warranty and responsive 24/7 customer support.

Similarly, the Ledger Nano X should be bought exclusively from the Ledger website or authorized resellers. This ensures you receive a genuine product with Ledger’s comprehensive warranty and top-notch customer service. Avoid third-party sellers to safeguard your funds and ensure you receive legitimate firmware updates.

Conclusion

Both the SafePal S1 and Ledger Nano X are excellent choices, and you won’t go wrong with either. Choose the SafePal S1 for budget-friendly, air-gapped security or the Ledger Nano X for a versatile, mobile-first solution. Select the wallet that aligns with your needs and trust both to keep your crypto safe.

Read also ↓

SafePal S1 vs. Ledger Nano S Plus

SafePal S1 vs Ledger Stax

FAQs

• What are the key differences between the SafePal S1 and Ledger Nano X?

The SafePal S1 uses a completely air-gapped design with QR code scanning for transactions, while the Ledger Nano X offers Bluetooth connectivity in addition to USB-C. The Ledger Nano X’s connectivity makes it more versatile for on-the-go use with mobile devices.

• Which wallet supports more cryptocurrency?

The SafePal S1 supports over 9,000 cryptocurrencies across multiple chains. The Ledger Nano X supports 500+ coins directly via Ledger Live and extends to 5,000+ via third-party wallets. Both wallets support a broad range, but Ledger has an edge in third-party compatibility.

• Which wallet offers better user experience for beginners?

The Ledger Nano X offers a more beginner-friendly experience with its intuitive Ledger Live app. While the SafePal S1’s QR-based design prioritizes security, its setup may feel less straightforward to beginners.

• What are the battery life capabilities of both wallets?

The SafePal S1 has a long-lasting battery that lasts up to 20 days on standby. The Ledger Nano X features a smaller 100mAh battery, providing up to 5 hours of active use.

• What are the pricing differences, and do the features justify the cost for each wallet?

The SafePal S1 is priced at $49.99, while the Ledger Nano X costs $149. SafePal offers great value for its robust security, but Ledger’s additional features, like Bluetooth and a premium build, justify its higher price for users needing advanced connectivity and ecosystem integration.

• What security features does each wallet offer beyond basic cold storage protection?

The SafePal S1 includes an anti-tamper self-destruct mechanism and multi-layer security sensors. The Ledger Nano X features a certified CC EAL5+ secure element and offers optional Ledger Recover for phrase backup.