Swing Trading vs Day Trading – Which is More Profitable?

  • Home
  • Swing Trading vs Day Trading – Which is More Profitable?
Compare Day Trading vs Swing Trading to decide which approach best fits your lifestyle, personality and goals. Our guide examines all the key considerations.

Before diving into the nitty gritty details of swing trading and day trading, let’s briefly define what they are at their core…

Day trading involves very short-term speculation, trying to profit from intraday price movements lasting minutes to hours. Day traders open and close positions within the same trading session, constantly monitoring real-time price changes on short-time frame charts across that period.

On the other hand, swing traders look to profit from bigger price swings over a period of several days to weeks. They aim to capture larger moves compared to day trading, holding positions from 2 days out to a couple of weeks typically.

Time Commitment Differences

Now that we know the core concepts, one major area they differ is the actual time commitment involved…

Time Differences Between Day and swing trading

Day trader

Day trading requires full-time focus on the charts and price action throughout the trading session, whether it be 4 hours or 11 hours depending on the market traded. Trades happen rapidly, demanding full-time monitoring and quick reactions to capitalize on small intraday moves under volatile market conditions. It is not a strategy suited for part-time attention.

Swing trader

Meanwhile, swing trading offers much more flexibility in terms of time commitment. Price movements play out over days and weeks, not minutes. This means swing traders can check the markets periodically when convenient to analyze potential trades without needing to sit and watch all day. Part-time swing trading is certainly feasible for those with other responsibilities.

The longer timeframes of swing trading allow entries and exits to happen on the trader’s schedule. Day trading only works if fully present during the oft-chaotic intraday ebb and flow.

Now that we have compared the time commitment, next we will explore the profit potential of each style…

Profit Potential Compared

Swing trading and day trading also differ when it comes to profit potential:

Comparing Profit Potential Between Swing and Day Trading

Scalping small gains vs riding larger moves

The high activity of day trading provides more opportunities to scalp small gains rapidly that can accumulate, though each win may only capture a few pips. Swing trading aims to ride out larger moves targeting bigger profit targets.

Day trader

For example, a day trader might aim to profit 10-30 pips on average per trade, scalping small intraday moves repeatedly, and building up gains through high volume. If risking 30 pips per trade at a 1:1 ratio, they would aim to gain those 30 pips in profits, closing trades in minutes to hours. Over 10 trades per day, even with a 50% win rate, could reasonably achieve 300 pips or profit if the losses are kept small.

Swing trader

A swing trader on the other hand might target 100+ pips per trade, risking 50 pips initially with a 2:1 profit ratio in mind. Even if only trading a couple of times per week with a 50% win rate, just one or two winning swing trades could secure those 100-200+ pips in profit over just a few days or weeks. Three 100-pip winners pay better than thirty 30-pip scalps.

As you can see from the examples, swing traders don’t need to use extreme leverage to make adequate returns since the larger moves mean bigger pip gains. Day trading often necessitates high leverage in pursuit of clipping small moves to create adequate winning trade value.

So while day trading promises excitement and nonstop action scalping small amounts, swing trading offers potentially more efficient gains. The longer holds allow revenues to accumulate with a focused set of trades rather than a scattershot approach.

Now, the longer holds of swing trading also impact risk management strategies…

Risk Management Differences

Risk Management Differences between a swing trader versus day trader

As mentioned in profit potential comparisons, day trading allows very tight stop losses on all positions, keeping risk capped to small amounts given the targets are smaller. However, this also could mean getting stopped out prematurely right before a bigger move.

Meanwhile, swing trading aims to capture larger gains which means using wider stop-loss levels to avoid getting kicked out too early while giving the trade enough breathing room as the longer-term swing plays out over days to weeks.

Day trader

For instance, a day trader taking 5 trades per day and risking 20 pips on each trade would only risk 100 pips (1% of trading capital if using 1% risk) throughout that trading session. If the share size and specific instrument allow it, they also could use a tighter stop of 10-15 pips to cut losses faster while aiming for smaller profit targets.

Swing trader

In contrast, a swing trader entering trades less frequently may use an initial 50 pip stop on high-probability setups, giving the trade adequate room to fluctuate as the expected swing plays out over several days or weeks. The profit potential might be 3 to 5 times larger than the risk, so while the stop distance is greater, risk as a percentage of reward is kept reasonable.

Consider for example, if a swing trader risks 50 pips to try to capture a 250 pip profit, that’s only 20% of potential gain risked vs the day trader risking 20% of a 20-30 pip target. The wider stop loss size is mitigated by improved risk/reward ratio efficiency.

Having covered the differences in stop loss, next, let’s examine the ideal trader personality suited for each style…

Ideal Trader Personalities

Day traders need to make many quick decisions every day reacting to changing market prices. This fits people who like action and fast-paced environments. They act first and think later. Patience is not their strength.

Swing traders only make a few trades per week or month. They study to find good trade setups and then wait patiently to enter. Immediate action and excitement is not for them. Analytics and strategy guide them, not impulsiveness.

Day trading attracts more impulse-driven personalities. The constant activity fuels their adrenaline. But it may stress those inclined to over analyze before acting.

Swing trading suits calm logical thinkers. Watching charts fluctuate all day without jumping in right away takes discipline. Filtering complexity into simplicity appeals to their nature.

So day trading favors the action-junkies who react rapidly without hesitation. Swing trading selects for even-tempered strategists who think before responding. Understand which you are to pick the approach that aligns.

Let’s now compare the main tactics each trader style employs…

Strategies and Skills for Success

Day Trader vs Swing Trader - Strategies and Skills

Learning technical indicators like RSI, moving averages, MACD, etc. can guide day and swing traders. But most novices are overwhelmed by the array of exotic tools… “Just show me where to enter and exit!” they exclaim.

A day trader may utilize 5-minute charts and fast moving averages to identify overbought/oversold signals, entering and exiting positions rapidly based on these. They also read short-term price action, spotting 1-minute chart breakdowns to get in and out for quick profits.

The swing trader on the other hand studies longer-term moving averages on daily charts to define the trend, while observing 4-hour chart patterns and support/resistance looking for bounces to enter. They hold for days or weeks targeting bigger gains.

Read also! What are the Best Indicators for Swing Trading?

Mastering reading real-time price action happens through screen time and pattern recognition for the day trader. Whereas the swing trader sharpens analysis skills by studying fundamentals and honing chart reading abilities across higher timeframes, then thoughtfully times market cycles.

Patience and discipline in adhering to wider stops and profit targets despite short-term whipsaws is vital for the swing trader over holding periods of days to months. The day trader keys in on rapid reactions and instinct.

Instruments to Trade

Both day traders and swing traders have a variety of markets to choose from – each with their own pros and cons. Forex and crypto tend to be most popular due to 24/7 accessibility and high liquidity needed for rapid entries/exits that short-term speculation necessitates.

Stocks also work well for day trading during main market hours providing tremendous volatility. However, overnight gaps on stocks and locking up capital requirements for regulators make them less ideal for swing trading. Commodity futures and options contracts meanwhile provide plenty of swing trade opportunities.

So forex and crypto lend themselves well to both day or swing traders given constant spot access and leverage availability. Stocks favor day trades typically while futures/options work better for swing trade duration holds. Traders pick the instrument that fits their strategy.

Cost Considerations

Higher trade frequency equals increased transaction costs.

Day Trader

A day trader making 50 or more trades per day could easily rack up $50 or more in commissions daily, translating to over $1000 a month in broker fees. Spread costs also take their toll, potentially several dollars per trade. Over months and years, these accrue significantly.

Read also! How Much Can You Make Day Trading With $1,000?

Swing Trader

Meanwhile, a swing trader making 2-5 trades per week may pay just $10-$20 total in commissions. And spread costs are minimized without excessive transactions. Over a year, this may amount to just a couple hundred dollars instead of several thousand in direct trading expenses for the active day trader.

Taxes also differentiate returns. A day trader realizing $100,000 in short-term capital gains could face a tax bill approaching $25,000 if in a high income bracket. Whereas the strategic swing trader can qualify profits as preferential long-term gains – cutting the tax liability in half potentially, saving thousands.

Next, let’s compare the overall pros and cons to weigh up swing trading vs day trading…

Pros and Cons of Swing Trading vs Day Trading

Let’s now take a look at their advantages and disadvantages so you can determine which strengths and weaknesses you possess, then pick the trading method that aligns best with your skills and preferences.

Day Trading Pros Day Trading Cons
🎒 Exciting action and constant stimuli πŸ•’ Requires nonstop focus and rapid reactions
πŸ’Ή Potential to scalp small profits repeatedly πŸ’° Large account needed to generate meaningful income
πŸ“ˆ Can capitalize on short-term volatility πŸ’Έ High fees and slippage costs accumulate
Swing Trading Pros Swing Trading Cons
🌍 More lifestyle freedom and flexibility πŸ€” Potential boredom and impatience
🎯 Bigger profit targets on occasional trades πŸ“‰ Lower trade frequency risks complacency
πŸ’Ό Tax efficiencies enhance actual bottom line πŸ“‰ Extended drawdowns if overtrading without edge

In summary, day trading appeals to hyperactive quick-thinking traders seeking constant stimuli. But it necessitates strong skill and mental stamina. Swing trading better suits patient strategic thinkers. But they still require discipline to execute high-probability trades only while avoiding complacency.

Swing Trading vs Day Trading – Which is More Profitable?

In the end, profitability comes down to the individual trader’s skillsets and risk management more than the inherent nature of either methodology. Both swing trading and day trading can prove tremendously profitable with discipline.

However, swing trading does provide certain efficiency advantages that enable potentially higher profit ceilings. The occasional larger profit targets compound faster over time without accumulating excessive transaction costs and spread fees from overtrading.

Extensive analysis helps swing traders identify high-probability trades with defined risk-reward asymmetry. Letting these trades target significant gains as broad market swings play out favors compounding winnings.

Meanwhile, most day traders lack conviction by scalping insufficient moves, bleeding hard-earned gains away through chronic impatience. Their income relies on extremely high volumes in the best case.

So while day trading promises excitement, swing trading delivers greater profitability for those with temperance and analytic capacities to earn large returns in efficient doses. Skilled swing traders need not chase every tick – instead awaiting and embracing ideal scenarios with patience and courage.

  • What is the main difference between day trading vs swing trading?

Timeframe – day trading holds trades intraday while swing trading holds trades for days to weeks.

  • Which is more profitable, day trading or swing trading?

Returns depend greatly on win rates, risk control, and volumes traded. But swing trading can achieve equal or higher returns than day trading with fewer transactions.

  • What is easier, day trading or swing trading?

Day trading likely poses a steeper initial learning curve to react rapidly. But neither is inherently easy – both demand extensive skill development.

  • Which suits part-time traders better, day trading or swing trading?

Swing trading fits a part-time schedule far easier given trades last days to weeks, not intraday. Daily commitment is not required.

  • Is my personality better for day trading or swing trading?

Impatient excitement-seekers may thrive day trading; whereas calculated patient types often succeed swing trading. Understand your innate preferences.